I just think drums are so pristine that they don't sound like they are in a room. Almost like it was recorded in space. (did you record them in space?)
My point is I feel like I am being fooled by a lot of bands with modern production. In the 80/90's a band rose to the top because there was nowhere to hide in the studio. Nowadays you can put lipstick on a pig and make things sound stellar.
Your techniques are amazing, sound awesome and are great for bands that are limited: But bands like Testament should be allowed to breathe a little more as they have the competency to sound amazing unaided.
Listen to the intro rolls (hard to make out) but on the cd you can tell he is hitting certain parts of the toms to get the roll to the toms to ring a certain way.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwCeUsy59ks&feature=related
Plus there are build up rolls on the snare that build up parts etc etc.
It is that aspect of the drums that left me disappointed: The subtleties were all squashed out into mega mix 2000 to sound regimented.
So while you are the best (the best....nothing even gonna bring you down..) I think the best bands like Testament and Nevermore should be a little more ghetto because the skills should shine (not the production).